Having considered all of the facts alleged and the arguments submitted by the parties, and for the reasons stated above, the Chairman rejects the Argentine Republic’s Proposal to Disqualify Professor Pierre Tercier and Professor Albert Jan van den Berg.

CONTENTS

A. PROCEDURAL HISTORY................................................................................................. 1
B. PARTIES’ ARGUMENTS REGARDING THE PROPOSAL TO DISQUALIFY
PROFESSORS TERCIER AND VAN DEN BERG AND THE ARBITRATORS’
EXPLANATIONS ........................................................................................................................ 12
1. Argentina’s Proposal for Disqualification ......................................................................... 12
2. Claimants’ Observations .................................................................................................... 14
3. Arbitrators’ Explanations ................................................................................................... 16
C. DECISION BY THE CHAIRMAN ................................................................................... 16
1. Request for Recommendation ............................................................................................ 16
2. Timeliness .......................................................................................................................... 16
3. Merits ................................................................................................................................. 17
D. DECISION ......................................................................................................................... 20

D. DECISION 

83. Having considered all of the facts alleged and the arguments submitted by the parties, and 

for the reasons stated above, the Chairman rejects the Argentine Republic’s Proposal to 

Disqualify Professor Pierre Tercier and Professor Albert Jan van den Berg. 

 

 

 

[Signed] 

______________________________________ 

Chairman of the ICSID Administrative Council 

Dr. Jim Yong Kim 

https://icsid.worldbank.org/ICSID/FrontServlet?requestType=CasesRH&actionVal=showDoc&docId=DC4152_En&caseId=C95